Suggestion:
Why not allow online access to the entire music collection. Benefits:

1) It would be a more efficient way for patrons to search and use the entire catalog. Multiple Patrons could access the same material at once. Easier to place music on a MP3 player.

2) It would reduce damage, scratches, lost material, etc.

3) Other Libraries could share their collections (interlibrary loan) - increasing the size of both collections at a minimal cost.

As a service project the Cubscouts/Boyscouts could use the computer room to move all of the CDs to a digital repository. (Many hands make light heavy work)